Internal Medicine and Cardiology Specialist Prof. Dr. Canan Karatay was temporarily banned from profession for 1 month due to her remarks about vaccines in a television program she attended in 2018. Prof. by Istanbul Medical Chamber. Dr. It was decided to ban Karatay from profession for 1 month and the decision was approved by the Turkish Medical Association High Honor Board. Following Karatay's objection to the decision, the Constitutional Court overturned the decision, considering Karatay's punishment for his statements as "interference with freedom of expression".
The Constitutional Court concluded that "the legal basis of the disciplinary penalty given due to medical explanations and the necessity of the intervention were not sufficiently demonstrated" and ruled that the decision be sent to the Ankara 14th Administrative Court for a retrial to eliminate the consequences of the violation.
Internal Medicine and Cardiology Specialist Prof. Dr. Canan Karatay stated that the decision to ban her from the profession was against the law and said that she stood behind her thoughts on vaccines. Prof. Dr. Karatay argued that medicine should not progress according to a certain pattern and made the following statements:
"It was already an illegal practice. After a speech I gave in 2018, the Istanbul Medical Chamber and the administrative court imposed a 1-month ban from profession. Of course, nothing like that happened; we objected to them, and finally, 8 years later, the Supreme Court made a decision saying that such a punishment could not be possible. He said, 'This is an illegal verdict, Karatay's expression is free, he has freedom of expression.' Because it has no legal basis and it is a wrong decision. That's why it's 14th again. He gave it back to the Administrative Court, saying, 'Take it and reconsider it.' Because I said that some vaccines were unnecessary, I said that they were dangerous. As a physician and an academic for 60 years, I was always attacked by those who practice 'Rockefeller medicine', but they never won. I still win all the cases. I have expressed what I think, but I am being accused by their servants of Rockefeller medicine because it has to be applied, because there was no such thing in the period we studied, saying 'this must be done, anything else is wrong'."
Prof said he believes that science will develop through the conflict of different ideas. Dr. Karatay stated that medicine is now a 'business'. Karatay said, "Everyone's opinion is different and should be different. Science develops by conflicting with different ideas. They do not put forward any arguments against what I say, they just want me to be silent, they want me not to talk. Why? Because medicine has become a business now. They serve that trade and they said it very well: 'Do not make him talk; when he talks, our sales decrease by 30 percent.' Because medicine is a business now. Medicine is actually a sacred art, as Aristotle said, and its object is a living human being. They may not accept arguments against my opinion because we have been trained that way and I implement it. Not everyone has to agree. I expect them to come up with an argument against this and another idea. They struggle to prevent me from speaking and they silence me. The Supreme Court said, 'Such illegality cannot be possible, Karatay has the right to express his opinion openly according to Article 26 of the Constitution, this is a violation of rights.' They do everything to keep me quiet and not talk. Science develops through the coincidence of ideas; "Science and knowledge cannot develop by being silent and being silenced," he said.