In our rapidly developing world, artificial intelligence
technologies continue to progress unabated. In addition to the conveniences
that artificial intelligence technologies offer to our lives, it is also a
matter of curiosity how to control them. Dr. Nuri Bingöl, Head of Üsküdar
University Artificial Intelligence Engineering Master's Programme, made
statements about how rapidly developing artificial intelligence technologies
should be controlled nationally and globally, what kind of limits should be
imposed and what obstacles are in front of all these. International authorities
agree that the disadvantages of artificial intelligence should be addressed as
well as its advantages. Drawing attention to the extraordinary progress of
artificial intelligence in the last few years and its consequences in the
fields where it is applied, Dr. Nuri Bingöl says that the development of
artificial intelligence technology should be subject to some regulations and
controls. Stating that the disagreements are about 'how and by whom this
supervision will be implemented', Bingöl emphasises that this authority should
not be thought of as being gathered in one hand.
How will the control
be in artificial intelligence?
Stating that many authorities who shape today's societies
with their thoughts and even people who play an important role in the
development of artificial intelligence share similar thoughts, Bingöl said,
"The extraordinary development of artificial intelligence in the last few
years and the results in the fields where it is used show that the development
in artificial intelligence technology should be subject to some regulations and
controls. The differences of opinion are not on this issue, but on 'how this
supervision will be implemented'." Referring to the reasons why the
discussions and disagreements are centred on how the supervision will be
implemented, Bingöl explained these reasons as follows: "Artificial
intelligence technologies are a great power and there are problems that will be
brought by the collection of this power in the hands of only one institution.
These technologies are a two-stage product by nature. The first is to develop
the capacity of artificial intelligence, and the second is to use it for a
specific purpose. Which of these two phases should be controlled or limited?
Which phase contains more potential threats or dangers? Naturally, the measures
that can be taken vary according to the answer to this question. The question
of 'how to implement' takes on a different meaning."
What will be the
level of control over technology?
Drawing attention to the level of control and limitation of
artificial intelligence, Bingöl said, "It should not be forgotten that
excessive control and limitation on technology leads to a decrease in the benefits
arising from the development of that technology. However, there are great
existential problems in front of humanity and artificial intelligence
technologies have great potential in these issues."
Bingöl quoted Andrew Ng, one of the important names of
artificial intelligence, as saying, "When I think about the existential
risks for a large part of humanity: The next pandemic, climate change and
consequent mass depopulation, another asteroid threat... Artificial
intelligence will be an important part of our solutions. So if we want humanity
to survive and thrive for the next thousand years, let's make AI work faster,
not slower.
Stating that the control and limitations of artificial
intelligence should not only be effective on the threat and danger dimension,
Bingöl said, "There is also an 'ethical' dimension as important as these.
Even with very small capacity artificial intelligence products, it can create
some personal violations and threats. In particular, a person, an institution
or a human community can be targeted.
Therefore, the need for supervision and limitations should not be
considered only for parties that produce or use artificial intelligence
technology with very large capacity. Supervision and limitations should be
valid for both large sized and small sized artificial intelligence
capacity."
Stating that it seems that it will take time for the
standardisation and regulations on how to implement supervision and
limitations, Bingöl said, "While discussions and ideas continue to develop
in this field, it is important to put some practical regulations and
regulations on artificial intelligence into past experiences such as the
European Union General Data Protection Regulation or the Personal Data
Protection Law as applied in our country and to create an administrative
framework. Because the steps taken for personal data security and ethics can
form an idea and practical basis on the control and limitations of artificial
intelligence. These regulations, which are built on from which source, in what
size and for what purpose the data is used, how it is protected and shared, are
an important element for the capacity building phase of artificial intelligence
and can at least form a control basis in this respect." He concluded.
Informatics Law is
important in this regard.
Stating that another factor is the management of computing
power and energy consumption, Bingöl said, "Controls and limitations in
this area have been able to solve some of the problems caused by the
'Blockchain' technology and contributed to the more positive direction of the
technology. Similar legislation may indirectly have an impact on artificial
intelligence technology." Drawing attention to the fact that first of all,
fake content produced by artificial intelligence should be identified and what
the sanctions should be should be decided, Bingöl said, "Not only content
that contains fake information, but also content that contains correct
information but is created by artificial intelligence to manipulate a group or
to gain benefits for a group should be prevented. Thanks to the user data
collected, all kinds of political and commercial campaigns created by
artificial intelligence targeting individuals should be limited so that free
will remains free. Without wasting time, we should start to establish the
relationship between the concepts of 'Access to Data and Use of Computing
Power' with the existing laws and regulations with an artificial
intelligence-oriented perspective. In particular, we should draw the attention
of 'Information Law' elements to this issue."
He spoke as follows. Emphasising that a technology that
people can easily reach and when it reaches, it can affect both their own and
others' lives should be controlled, Dr. Lecturer. Prof. Dr. Nuri Bingöl said,
"However, it does not seem possible to establish a control mechanism over
all artificial intelligence models that can only be created with a computer and
some mathematical knowledge." Stating that the fact that artificial
intelligence technology is subject to control and limitation should not be
considered as inevitably gathering this authority in one hand, Bingöl concluded
his words as follows:
"In fact, today's technologies focus on decentralised
infrastructures and many developments are taking place in this field. Moreover,
the fact that artificial intelligence technologies, once produced, can operate
as embedded systems without being connected to any centre or even to the
internet provides freedom at least for the usage phase. For artificial
intelligence systems with this capability, it is almost impossible to establish
a centralised connection and control, as it is seen in every field today."